Family-Style Italian Icon: How Tony’s Di Napoli Brings Tradition to NYC

For over three decades, Tony’s Di Napoli has stood as a beloved institution in New York City's dining scene, serving up hearty, family-style Italian meals that have won over both locals and tourists. With a Forbes review calling it "as good if not better than some of the 'trendy' Italian restaurants of the moment," this restaurant has proven that classic red-sauce comfort never goes out of style.

From Passion Project to Iconic Institution

Tony’s Di Napoli was founded in 1990 on the Upper East Side by partners Herb Wetanson—of Wetson's Hamburgers fame—and his son Greg Wetanson. The duo drew inspiration from their family’s favorite Italian haunt, Don Peppe’s in Ozone Park, Queens. Their goal was to create an elegant yet value-oriented take on classic family-style Italian dining in a large, welcoming space. The concept quickly became a hit, and in 2002, the Wetanson family expanded to the Theater District in Midtown Manhattan, taking over the historic space that once housed Rosoff’s Restaurant on West 43rd Street. Today, Tony’s Di Napoli operates two iconic locations: one in Times Square (147 West 43rd Street) and the original on the Upper East Side (1081 3rd Avenue).

What Tony’s Di Napoli Offers

Tony’s Di Napoli is renowned for its family-style Italian menu featuring authentic red-sauce recipes. All dishes are served in generous portions meant for sharing, encouraging a communal dining experience. The restaurant offers dine-in, take-out, and delivery services at both locations, with hours accommodating lunch and dinner daily. In addition to regular service, Tony’s provides catering and specialized menus for parties and groups, making it a popular choice for celebrations and gatherings. Guests can also purchase gift cards and order online for convenience.

Key Services

• Dine-In at both locations with a lively, energetic atmosphere

• Take-Out for enjoying Tony’s favorites at home

• Delivery through the restaurant’s online ordering

• Catering for events and special occasions

• Parties & Groups with customizable menus

• Gift Cards available on their website

What Makes Tony’s Di Napoli Special

Beyond the food, Tony’s Di Napoli stands out for its unique atmosphere and commitment to hospitality. The Times Square location features walls adorned with oil-painted caricatures of Broadway stars, creating what is now one of Broadway’s most impressive walls of fame—a nod to the theater district’s vibrant spirit. This dedication to creating a memorable environment, combined with warm, attentive service, has earned the restaurant a loyal following. Reviews on TripAdvisor, Yelp, Google, and OpenTable consistently praise the friendly staff, quick service, and delicious food. One Google reviewer called it “absolutely top-notch Italian food with a wonderfully warm family atmosphere.” The generous portions and emphasis on sharing align with the restaurant’s family-style tradition, making every meal feel like a celebration. Over the years, Tony’s Di Napoli has become a staple not just for its cuisine but for the sense of community it fosters.

Who Is Tony’s Di Napoli For?

Tony’s Di Napoli caters to a wide range of diners, but it is especially popular among families and groups looking for a shared dining experience. The family-style servings are ideal for large parties, and the welcoming atmosphere suits both casual meals and special occasions. Theater-goers flock to the Times Square location for pre- or post-show dinners, attracted by its proximity to Broadway and its lively, high-energy vibe. Tourists seeking authentic, no-fuss Italian food also find Tony’s a reliable favorite, while locals return for the consistent quality and comforting flavors. Whether you’re celebrating a milestone or just craving a hearty plate of pasta, Tony’s Di Napoli offers a place where everyone feels at home.

Plan Your Visit

Tony’s Di Napoli invites you to experience its time-honored family-style dining. Both locations are open daily for dine-in, take-out, and delivery. To make reservations, view menus, or order online for pickup or delivery, visit their website at www.tonysnyc.com. For larger groups, the restaurant offers special party menus and catering options. Join the countless guests who have made Tony’s Di Napoli a New York City tradition—book your table or place your order today.